|
The Truth About Pope Pius XII by Sister Margherita Marchione. Ph.D. |
Thursday, March 26, 2009 |
Pope Pius XII and Hitler
Pope Pius XII was not a German collaborator nor was he pro-Nazi. Neither was he inactive nor silent. As a member of the Catholic Church, I resent the blatant accusations against the diplomacy of the Pope and the Church during World War II. This is not only indecent journalism but it also an injustice toward a man who saved more Jews than any other person, including Oscar Schindler and Raoul Wallenberg. Unfortunately even in the new Holocaust Museum at Battery Park in New York City the Pope is unjustly criticized. It is historically inaccurate to charge him with "silence." Should the media be allowed to perpetuate such falsehoods? Documents prove that these misrepresentations are untrue. Pius XII spoke out as much as he could, and was able to do more with actions than with words. To the very end, he was convinced that, should he denounce Hitler publicly, there would be retaliation. And there was. Whenever protests were made, treatment of prisoners worsened immediately. Robert Kempner, the American who served as deputy chief of the Nuremburg war-crimes tribunal, wrote: "All the arguments and writings eventually used by the Catholic Church against Hitler only provoked suicide; the execution of Jews was followed by that of Catholic priests." Pius XII—through his public discourses, his appeals to governments, and his secret diplomacy—was engaged more than any other individual in the effort to curb the war and rebuild the peace. Documents show that Pius XII was in contact with the German generals who sought to overthrow Hitler. Documents also show that the Jewish community received enormous help: Pius XII’s personal funds ransomed Jews from Nazis. Papal representatives in Croatia, Hungary, and Romania intervened to stop deportations. The Pope called for a peace conference involving Italy, France, England, Germany, and Poland in 1939, in a last-minute bid to avert bloodshed. An interesting document is the testimony of Albert Einstein who, disenchanted by the silence of universities and editors of newspapers, stated in Time magazine (December 23, 1940): "Only the Church stood squarely across the path of Hitler’s campaign for suppressing truth. …The Church alone has had the courage and persistence to stand for intellectual truth and moral freedom." Indeed, executing the directives of Pope Pius XII, religious men and women opened their doors to save the Jews. Never were the Jews and the Vatican so close as during World War II. The Vatican was the only place on the continent where they had any friends. Pope Pius XII’s response to the plight of the Jews was to save as many as possible. Yet little has been done to stop the criticism of Pius XII that began in 1963, when Rolf Hochhuth portrayed him as a Nazi collaborator in the play "The Deputy." In contrast to the image suggested by this play, Vatican records indicate that the Church operated an underground railroad that rescued 800,000 European Jews from the Holocaust. After a careful study of available documents, whoever is interested in the truth will no longer condemn the actions of Pope Pius XII’s words and the Catholic Church during this tragic period. An honest evaluation of Pope Pius XII’s words and actions will exonerate him from false accusations and show that he has been unjustly maligned. The Pope neither favored nor was favored by the Nazis. The day after his election (March 3, 1939), the Nazi newspaper, Berliner Morganpost stated its position clearly: "the election of Cardinal Pacelli is not accepted with favor in Germany because he was always opposed to Nazism." The New York Times editorial (December 25, 1942) was specific: "The voice of Pius XII is a lonely voice in the silence and darkness enveloping Europe this Christmas...He is about the only ruler left on the Continent of Europe who dares to raise his voice at all." The Pope’s Christmas message was also interpreted in the Gestapo report: "in a manner never known before...the Pope has repudiated the National Socialist New European Order [Nazism]. It is true, the Pope does not refer to the National Socialists in Germany by name, but his speech is one long attack on everything we stand for. …Here he is clearly speaking on behalf of the Jews." Perhaps the rest of the world should interpret the Pope’s words as they were meant and, undoubtedly, correctly understood by the Nazis, i.e.: POPE PIUS XII WAS ALWAYS OPPOSED TO NAZISM. The Jewish Community publicly acknowledged the wisdom of Pope Pius XII’s diplomacy. In September 1945, Dr. Joseph Nathan—who represented the Hebrew Commission—stated "Above all, we acknowledge the Supreme Pontiff and the religious men and women who, executing the directives of the Holy Father, recognized the persecuted as their brothers and, with great abnegation, hastened to help them, disregarding the terrible dangers to which they were exposed." In 1958, at the death of Pope Pius XII, Golda Meir sent an eloquent message: "We share in the grief of humanity. …When fearful martyrdom came to our people, the voice of the Pope was raised for its victims. The life of our times was enriched by a voice speaking out about great moral truths above the tumult of daily conflict. We mourn a great servant of peace."
Labels: History |
posted by Bro. Terence @ 12:14 AM |
|
1 Comments: |
-
Very well stated and so true. Much of the misguided criticism of Pope Pius XII is countered in The Myth of Hitler’s Pope, A book written by a Jewish Rabbi that uses solid research and documents to dismantle the nonsense attacking the Pope.
|
|
<< Home |
|
|
|
|
About Me |
Name: Bro. Terence
Home: Sta. Maria, Bulacan, Philippines
About Me: pogi?
See my complete profile
|
Previous Post |
|
Archives |
|
Catholic Blog By the
Priest and Deacon |
Ad Maiorem Dei Gloriam - Fr.
Patrick Fairbanks, SJ
Adam's Ale - Fr. Valencheck,
Ohio
Amigos de Banica - Fr. O'Hare
Anamchara - Msgr. Eric R. Barr,
Illinois
AtonementOnline - Fr. Christopher
G. Phillips, Texas
Bangor to Bobbio - Fr. Seán
Coyle, Philippines
Bear Witness to the Light - Fr.
John L., Massachusetts
A Beggar for Love - Fr. Daren J.
Zehnle, Illinois
Being is Good - Deacon Dana,
Florida
Bekeh's Blog - Fr. Bekeh
Utietiang
Bekeh's Homilies - Fr. Bekeh
Utietiang
Bishop William Lori's Blog -
Bishop William Lori, Connecticut
The Black Biretta - Padre
Giovanni, Pennsylvania
Blessed is the Kingdom - Fr.
Christian Mathis, Tennessee
Blog do Padre Luizinho - Fr.
Luizinho, Brazil
Blog do Padre Roger Luis - Fr.
Roger Luis, Brazil
Blog of Fr. Peter Leung - Fr.
Peter Leung
Bonfire of the Vanities - Fr.
Martin Fox, Ohio
Breaking the Word - Fr. Chris
The Bridge - Fr. Frank Majka, SJ,
Wisconsin
Byzantine Ramblings - The
Byzantine Rambler
Called by Name - Fr. Kyle
Schnippel, Ohio
Cardinal Seán's Blog - Seán
Cardinal O'Malley, Massachusetts
Caritas Christi Urget Nos - Fr.
Pat Mulcahy, Illinois
A Cascade Catholic - Deacon Al
Ardon, Washington
Catholic Spiritual Direction -
Fr. John Bartunek, LC, New York
Catholic Under the Hood - Fr.
Seraphim Beshoner
Catholic Vision - Fr. Andrew,
South Dakota
Catholicism, Scholarship &
Fun - Fr. James Lloyd, CSP, New York
Catholikos Diakonos - Deacon
Scott Dodge, Utah
CFR Sudan Mission - Fr. Herald
Joseph Brock, CFR, Sudan
Claretian Teaching Ministry - Fr.
John Hampsch, CMF, California
Clerical Whispers - Sotto Voce,
Ireland
Communio ~ Fr. Richard Healey -
Fr. Richard Healey, Australia
A Concord Pastor Comments -
ConcordPastor, Massachusetts
Confessionário dum Padre -
Confessional, Portugal
CSVF Blog - Fr. Aquinas, OP, New
York
CUSA Blog - Fr. Lawrence
Jagdfeld, OFM
Da Mihi Animas - Padre Steve, New
Jersey
De Fide Catholica - Fr. Laurent
Demets, Arkansas
Deacon Dan Wright - Dan Wright,
Texas
Deacon Tom Stonecipher - Tom
Stonecipher, Georgia
Deacon Tony's Place - Deacon
Tony, New York
The Deacon's Bench - Deacon Greg
Kandra, New York
Deacon's Diary - Group
Deo Adiuvante - Fr. Leo McDowell,
Montana
Diakonia - Deacon Patrick Kearns,
California
Diario de Fray Nelson M. - Fr.
Nelson Medina, Columbia
Diary of a Pilgrimage - Deacon
Shawn Tunink, Illinois
Diary of a Rookie Priest - Fr.
Mark Mossa, SJ
Discalced Carmelite Friars - Fr.
Adam
Do Whatever He Tells You - Fr.
Mitchell Zimmerman, Kansas
Dom Donald's Blog - Dom Donald,
Scotland
Domine, da mihi hanc aquam! - Fr.
Philip Powell, O.P. , Texas
Dominican History - Fr. John
Frederick Hinnebusch, OP & Fr. Stephen Ryan, OP
Dominican Liturgy - Fr. Augustine
Thompson, OP, Virginia
DominicanSingapore - Fr.
David
Douloscross Web Journal - Deacon
Harry Martin, California
Eloi's Voice - Fr. Rich
Brensinger, Pennsylvania
Evening Devotions - Fr. Scott
Bailey, C.SS.R., Massachusetts
Eyes of Faith - Fr. Larry
Gearhart, Ohio
Father Anthony Ho - Fr. Anthony
Ho, Canada
Father Bill Dinga's Blog - Father
Bill Dinga
Father Dennis - Fr. Dennis,
Iowa
Father Dylan's Sermons - Fr.
Dylan James, England
Father Jim Chern's Blog - Fr. Jim
Chern, New Jersey
Father Joe - Fr. Joe,
Maryland
Father Ray's 'Other' Corner - Fr.
Ray Suriani
Father Sullivan - Fr. Thomas
Sullivan, Florida
A Few Simple Words - Fr. Bob,
Washington, DC
Fiat Volvntas Tua - Fr. Joe,
Philippines
Fire, Salt, and Light - Arthur
Joseph, Canada
Followers of the Way - Deacon
Jacob Maurer
Forest Murmurs - Fr. Michael
Brown, UK
Fortuna's Fortune - Fr. Stan
Fortuna
Fr. Bob's Corner - Fr. Bob
MacDonald, Canada
Fr. Bosco Galli - Fr. Bosco
Galli, UK
Fr. Brendan - Fr. Brendan Manson,
California
Fr. Carmen Mele, Dominican
Preacher - Fr. Carmen Mele, Texas
Fr. H. Paul - Fr. H. Paul Kim,
Ohio
Fr. JC Maximilian's Homilies & Spiritual
Reflections - Fr. JC Maximilian, New Jersey
Fr. Mildew - Fr. Michael Clifton,
UK
Fr. Victor Brown's Catholic Daily
Message - Fr. Victor Brown
Fr. West's Catholic Blog - Fr.
Peter West, New York
Fred's Place - Fr. Ed Burns, Ohio
FRIARside Chats - Fr. Chuck
Talley, OFM, California
Friends with Christ - Fr. Richard
Aladics & Fr. Julian Green, UK
Gloria Olivae - Fr. Odon de
Castro, Philippines
God's Word to Us - Fr. Dominic
Canh Tran, SDB
Gone Walkabout - Fr. Jim
McDermott, SJ, Australia
The Great Commandment - Fr. David
Hudgens, Michigan
The Hermeneutic of
Continuity - Fr. Tim Finigan, England
Hills of the North, Rejoice
- Deacon Peter Simpson, Scotland (formerly The Deacon of
Ham) Holy Priesthood - Fr. Joel
& Fr. Benjamin
Homilies and Reflections from
Australia - Fr. John Speekman,
Australia
Homilies of a Jesuit - The
Jesuit
How Can I Keep from
Singing? - Fr. Ernie Davis,
Missouri
Husband, Father, Deacon,
Man - Deacon Patrick, Colorado
I Am Not Ashamed of the
Gospel - Deacon Steve, Michigan
I Love You! - Deacon
Randy
In and Out of Season -
Archbishop Angel Lagdameo, Philippines
Jamesaubrey - JamesAubrey,
Oklahoma
Jesus Goes to Disney World
- Fr. Austin Murphy, Maryland Journal of God's Call - Fr.
Christopher Rossman, Kansas
Kingmancatholic - Fr. James
Weldon, Kansas
Laus Crucis - Fr. Paul
Francis Spencer, CP, Scotland
Life's Crosses- Fr.
Aloysius Ong, Singapore
Living Sacrifice - Fr.
Christopher M. Mahar, Rhode Island
Lux Vera - Fr. David
Thoroughgood, Australia
Mary, Our Mother - Totus
Tuus and RomanCatholic Deacon
Mary's Anawim - Fr. Rick
Heilman, Wisconsin
Me Monk. Me Meander - Fr.
Stephanos, OSB
Mercy and Mary - Fr. John
Larson, Washington D.C.
A Minor Friar - Friar
Minor
Misericórdia e Verdade -
Padre Reinaldo, Brazil
The Monastic Preacher -
Prior Peter, OSB
Monks and Mermaids - Fr.
David Bird, OSB, Peru
Monk's News - Fr. Kenneth,
OSB, Missouri
My World - Fr. Phil, New
Hampshire
Oasis of Peace: Mission to
Iraq - MCITL: Meeting Christ in the
Liturgy, Iraq
Omne Quod Spirat, Laudet
Dominum! - Fr. Cory Sticha, Montana
One Monk of the Order of St.
Benedict - Fr. Stephanos, OSB
Orthometer - Fr. Erik
Richtsteig, Utah
Overheard in the Sacristy -
Fr. L.W. Gonzales, Arizona
Owl of the Remove - The Owl
of the Remove, Vermont
Padre Antonio Aguiar - Fr.
Antonio Aguiar, Brazil
Padre Cleidimar - Fr.
Cleidimar Moreira, Brazil
Pan de la Semana - Fr.
Vitaliano Chito Dimaranan, SDB, Philippines
Parish the Thought - Fr.
Bud Pelletier, Arizona
Per Agrum Ad Sacrum - Fr.
Vitaliano Chito Dimaranan, SDB, Philippines
Peregrinus - Pilgrim On,
California
Prayer on the Hill - Fr.
Milton E. Jordan, Washington, DC
Priest - Fr. Jessie
Somosierra, Jr., Philippines
A Priestly Commentary - Fr.
V, Massachusetts
Printed as Preached - Fr.
Cávana Wallace, California
Prior's Blog - Prior Peter,
OSB, Illinois
Prophetic Fraternal
Franciscan - Fr. Kim Studwell, OFM,
Wisconsin
Quod Scripsit - Eques
Rationabile Obsequium -
FrB
Rev Fr. Bosco's Space - Fr.
Bosco, UK
RevRobJack.com - Fr. Rob
Jack, Ohio
Rifugio San Gaspare - Fr.
Jeffrey Keyes C.PP.S., California
Roman Miscellany - Fr.
Nicholas Schofield, England
The Sacred Congregation of
Rites - Scranton Priest
Scriptural Reflections -
Fr. Bert, SM
Seek His Face - Fr. Ronald
Check, Pennsylvania
Servant and Steward - Fr.
Daren Zehnle, Illinois
A Shepherd's Voice - Fr.
John Molloy, California
Shouts in the Piazza - Guy
Sylvester, New Jersey
The Speakin' Deacon -
Deacon John, Kentucky
Spes Unica - Fr. Stephen,
CSC
Spiritual Friendship - Fr.
Antonio, Lebanon
The Splendor of the Church
- Fr. Abe, CRS, Philippines
St. Andrew Q&A - Fr.
Greg
St. Marie's Gem - Fr.
Francis Wadsworth
St. Mary Magdalen, Brighton,
UK - Fr. Ray Blake, UK
St. Michael's Cyber Parish
- Fr. James Proffitt, Maryland
St. Vincent Archabbey
Vocations - Fr. Fred Byrne, OSB,
Pennsylvania
Standing on my Head - Fr.
Dwight Longenecker, South Carolina
The Sunday Homily - Fr.
James Farfaglia, Texas
There is an Appointed Time for
Everything... - Fr. James Willard
Northrop, Washington
Thoughts from the Lune
Valley - Fr. Paul Harrison, UK
Thrown Back - Fr. Rob
Johansen, Michigan
Thy Nose to the Marble -
Fr. Christopher Decker
To Find Fruit - Paul D.
Panaretos, SJ, Ohio
The Truth Will Make You Free
- Fr. Robert Connor, New York
Two Edge Talk - Deacon Tim
& Cyndi
The Ultramontanist - Padre
Paulus, Washington, DC
viewpoints - Archbishop
Oscar Cruz, Philippines
Virtual Retreat - Fr. Rory
Pitstick, SSL, Washington
Vita Mea - Fr. Dennis,
Indiana
Vocations Views - Fr. Todd
J. Petersen, Minnesota
Vultus Christi - Fr. Mark
Daniel Kirby, O.Cist.
weCatholic.org - Deacon
Patrick, Colorado
What Does the Prayer Really
Say? - Fr. John Zuhlsdorf
White Around the Collar -
Fr. Dana Christensen, South Dakota
Word Incarnate - Abbot
Joseph, California
Young Fogeys - Fr. Jay
Toborowsky, New Jersey
2000 Stories - Fr. Thomas
Dowd, Canada (formerly Waiting in Joyful
Hope)
21st Century Catholic -
Deacon Jacob Maurer,
Washington |
|
Catholic Blog By the Lay
and Religious |
Ad Saeculum - Br. Robert, OP
Air
Maria - Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate,
Connecticut
All Roads Lead to Rome! - Br.
Tom, New York
An Ambassador for Christ - Br.
Christopher Gaffrey, Italy
Amy Hereford, CSJ - Amy Hereford,
CSJ, Belgium
Anchorhold for Jesus: Ireland - A
Nun, Ireland
BayaThread - Baya Clare, CSJ,
Minnesota
Best Catholic Books - Sr. Julia,
Louisiana
Bloggin' Friar at franciscans.org
- Friar Matt
Blogging Brother Brian - Br.
Brian, Texas
Br. Michael-Godfrey's Prayer -
Br. Michael-Godfrey
Bukas Palad - Adrian Danker, SJ,
Philippines
Caritas Christi Urget Nos! - Sr.
Cora
Carmelitana - Paul Chandler,
Italy
Carmelite Sisters
Caught Up in God
Chronicles of the Daily Grind -
Brodiz, Philippines
Cistercian Vocation - Sr.
Eleanor, Ireland
The City and the World - Joe
Koczera, SJ, New York
Colophon: A Monastery Blog - Holy
Trinity Monastery, UK
Contemplative Horizon -
Contemplative Woman
Crux of the Matter - Amy L.
Cavender, CSC, Indiana
Colwich Novitiate - Noviceship,
England
Crying Out in the Wilderness -
Richard Beebe, SJ, Michigan
CSJ Novitiate - Group
Day by Day - Sr. Lynn,
Missouri
Deo Gratia - Nader's Blog - Nader
Ata, Texas
The Digital Nun - Sister Judy
Connor, CDP
Discover God in the Everyday. With
us. - Ferdinand Benedictines, Indiana
Dominican Cooperator Brother -
Br. Paul, OP, Missouri
Dominican Sisters of Blauvelt -
Dominican Sisters, New York
Franciscan Footprints - Sr.
Veronica
Franciscan Life - Sr. Ann Marie,
Pennsylvania
Franciscan Musings - Rashfriar,
Washington, DC
Franciscan Sisters of Christian
Charity - Group
A Friar Style? - Freddie
From Marbury's Hilltop - St. Jude
Monastery, Alabama
Happynun Thinks Aloud -
Happynun
Hell Burns - Sr. Helena Burns,
Chicago
Hope-Full Signs - Sr. Judith, New
Jersey
IHM
Calling - Sister Mary Bea, Michigan
In the Shadow of His Wings -
Passionist Nuns, Kentucky
The Itinerant's Path - Br.
Vincent J. Celeste, FMS, Philippines
A Jesuit's Journey - Ryan Duns,
SJ
The Journey - Sr. Paulina Quinn,
OP
Kicking and Screaming - Tom
Gibbons, CSP
La Paz de Susan - Susan Dewitt,
CSJP, Washington
The Last Brother? Not if I Can Help
It! - Br. James Hayes, England
Life at the Convent - Sr. Mary
Lou, Minnesota
Life at the Monastery of St.
Gertrude
The Life of a New Sister - Sr.
Nicole Trahan, Texas
Life on Lotus Lane - Dominican
Nuns, Texas
Light through Stained-Glass
Windows - Susan Doubet, OSB
Little Portion Hermitage - Friar
Rex, Maine
Live Jesus! - a Visitation Nun,
Washington D. C.
Living the Zeal of Benedict -
Marilyn Schauble, OSB, Pennsylvania
Meg Funk - Sr. Meg Funk,
Indiana
Monastery Podcast - Benedictine
Sisters of Perpetual Adoration
Monastic Moments - Sr. Patricia,
Washington
Monastic Musings - Edith, OSB,
Minnesota
Monastics on a Journey - Sister
Vicki Ix, OSB, Virginia
Moniales - Dominican Nuns, New
Jersey
Monks on a Mission - Monks of
Schuyler, Nebraska
Musings of a Discerning Woman -
Susan Rose Francois, CSJP, New Jersey
My Movies - Sr. Rose Pacatte,
FSP, California
Notes from Stillsong Hermitage -
Sister Laurel M. O'Neal, Erem Dio, California
Nunblog - Sr. Anne FSP,
Illinois
NunEssential - Sr. MJ
A
Nun's Life - Julie Vieira, IHM
Nunsuch - Sandy Yost, CSJ,
Michigan
On a PENsive Mood - Br. Donnie
Duchin Duya, SDB, Philippines
One Mind and Heart Intent Upon
God - West Coast Augustianians
"Open Wide the Doors to Christ!"
- Sr. Marianne Lorraine Trouve FSP, Massachusetts
OPreach - Sr. Pat Farrell, OP,
California
Other than Being - Br. Thomas
Gricoski, OSB, Indiana
The Passionist Charism -
Passionistcharism, Australia
Pause for Prayer - Sr. Janet
PR Woman for Christ - Sister Mary
Peter
Reflections of an RSCJ - Helen
Rosenthal, RSCJ, Florida
Religious Life Rocks! - Sr. Katy,
Wisconsin
Renungan Dan Inspirasi Harian -
Reynaldo Fulgentio Tardelly, S.X., Indonesia
Running the Race of Life -
Jonathan St. Andre
The School Sisters of St. Francis
- Sr. Mary Michael and Sr. Maryana, Texas
Sister Christer - Sr. Christine Wilcox OP,
California
Sisters of the Gospel of Life -
Sr. Andrea & Sr. Roseann
Sisters of the Holy Family's Web
Log - Sisters of the Holy Family,
California
"So That in All Things...God May Be
Glorified" - Sr. Nicolette Etienne, OSB,
Indiana
A Space for Seeking and Deepening
- Sr. Margaret Kerry
Sub Tuum - Br. Stephen, O.Cist.,
Wisconsin
Subiaco Abbey - Monks of Subiaco,
Arkansas
The Story of a Vocation/La Historia de una
Vocación - Sr. Helga, Texas
Take with You Words - Sr.
Genevieve Glen, OSB and Edith, OSB
Theology of the Body - Sr. Anne,
Illinois
Under a Chindolea - Markel, SJ
& Mason Slidell
A Vow of Conversation - Macrina
Walker, OCSO, Netherlands
Within and Beyond - Dom Lawrence,
OSB, New Mexico
Witness Christ: Walking through Life with
God - Luuk Dominiek Jansen, OP, Ireland
1 Franciscan Way - 1 Franciscan
Way, Illinois 100%
Katolikong Pinoy- Kuya Francis
|
|
Very well stated and so true. Much of the misguided criticism of Pope Pius XII is countered in The Myth of Hitler’s Pope, A book written by a Jewish Rabbi that uses solid research and documents to dismantle the nonsense attacking the Pope.